[MyPemCharlie]

I almost had Charlie weaned off too many treats as training rewards. Then he became a teenager. LOL I'm back to bribing and luring him with lots of food. I put his whole day's ration of food in a ziploc, and he gets a small breakfast. I give him quite a bit of kibble as rewards during the day, and whatever's left is his dinner. Other than that, I keep little frozen packets of diced boiled chicken anytime we need "extra" temptation, and we just starting using more peanut butter yesterday for walks, which I'll wean him off later.

I think the apples and carrots for treats is a great idea!